Files
foxhunt/crates
jgrusewski 7b3309edcc fix(rl): eliminate atomicAdd in PPO+DQN loss reduction (F4.1)
Replaces atomicAdd accumulators in `ppo_clipped_surrogate_fwd` and
`dqn_distributional_q_bwd` with per-batch [B] outputs + a dedicated
single-block tree-reduce kernel. Per feedback_no_atomicadd.

Root cause: `ss_pi_loss_dev_ptr` was zero-init at trainer construction
but never reset between steps; the PPO atomicAdd accumulated across
every step since startup. Result: `loss.pi` = step_count × mean_per_step,
bit-exact step-count fingerprints:
  - local 1k × ~9 ≈ 9080 ✓
  - cluster 20k × ~1200 ≈ 24M ✓

The DQN distributional Q kernel had the same atomicAdd pattern. Its
trainer caller happened to memset between launches in dqn_replay_step
so the symptom was masked, but the anti-pattern was identical. Fixed
in the same commit per the user's "atomicAdd should not be used at all"
reminder.

Local smoke (RTX 3050, b=16, 1k steps, seed=16962):

  step | l_pi (pre → post)  | l_q (pre → post)
   100 |   27.5 → 0.56      |  18.1 → 0.19
   500 |  743.1 → 4.59      |  93.3 → 0.19
   999 | 9080.5 → 65.1      | 186.1 → 0.19

l_q now bit-flat at per-step mean (~0.19) — no step-count fingerprint.
l_pi grows organically with policy excursion (PPO surrogate magnitude
when ratio→clamp_max under Q-distillation-driven policy updates),
which is the legitimate diagnostic the prior staleness was burying.

Changes:
  - ppo_clipped_surrogate_fwd: scalar [1] outputs → per-batch [B]
  - dqn_distributional_q_bwd: remove atomicAdd; per_batch[B] only
  - ppo_loss_reduce_b.cu (NEW): two block tree-reduce kernels
      • ppo_loss_reduce_b (dual: PPO loss + entropy loss)
      • mean_reduce_b_f32 (single, reused by DQN head)
  - PolicyHead + DqnHead: load reducer cubin, add reduce_loss_to_scalar
  - Trainer: allocate ss_pi_loss_per_b_d + ss_pi_loss_entropy_per_b_d,
    invoke reducer after each backward (PPO + DQN replay paths)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-05-31 14:40:58 +02:00
..