Defines verdict criteria for the train-qsltr smoke at commit 5106e3b1:
- Mechanism activity (eval_dist, intent_dist, dist_q/h/f)
- WR signal (last_epoch_win_rate vs 46% baseline → 50%+ target)
- Stability (health, action_entropy, no regression)
Possible outcome table maps WR + dist pattern combinations to next-action
recommendations (Phase D vs tune vs revert vs investigate).
Deliberately deferred from this smoke: W[0..4] direct readback via mapped
pinned + HEALTH_DIAG log line (avoids bug risk during smoke window).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
a57ec3da8b