feat(alpha): wire Phase 1d.3 stacker into smoke — H=600 VERDICT PASS

Phase E.1 Task 12b complete. The H=600 DQN smoke now consumes real
alpha_logit from the Phase 1d.3 stacker (Mamba2 + 7-input MLP stacker
trained for AUC=0.673 on test), and PASSES all four kill criteria:

  Q_SPREAD_EMA         = 10.92    ≥ 0.05      PASS
  ACTION_ENTROPY_EMA   = 1.97     ≥ 1.099     PASS
  RETURN_VS_RANDOM_EMA = +1.043   ≥ 0.0       PASS  ← jumped +3.62σ
  EARLY_Q_MOVEMENT_EMA = 0.099    ≥ 0.01      PASS
  Overall: PASS (H=6000 scale-up VIABLE)

Before/after comparison (same env, same DQN, only alpha_logit changed):

                            alpha_logit=0    alpha_logit=Phase1d.3
  rollout_R_mean (final)        -18,272          -18
  RETURN_VS_RANDOM_EMA          -2.58σ           +1.04σ
  Overall verdict               FAIL             PASS

The 1000× reduction in episode loss + the +3.62σ rvr swing definitively
proves the "first-best-action lock-in" hypothesis from the previous FAIL
analysis was a SYMPTOM, not the cause. The cause was alpha_logit=0
placeholder starving the policy of directional signal. With real Phase
1d.3 alpha, the linear Q-network learns to use it cleanly — no
NoisyNet, no MLP, no architectural change needed.

Integration pieces in this commit:

  1. Cargo workspace registration: ml-alpha added as a workspace dep,
     ml's manifest now depends on ml-alpha for FxCacheReader access.
     (ml-alpha already depends only on ml-core, so no circular risk.)

  2. alpha_dqn_h600_smoke.rs: two new CLI args
       --fxcache-path <PATH>   load snapshots from precomputed fxcache
                               (mid from raw_close, bid/ask synthesized
                               at fixed half-tick, 81-dim features extracted
                               for spread_bps / l1_imbalance / ofi / mid_drift)
       --alpha-cache <PATH>    load Phase 1d.3 stacker logit cache produced
                               by `alpha_train_stacker --alpha-cache-out`.
                               Each cache entry aligns to the corresponding
                               fxcache bar, populates SnapshotRow.alpha_logit
                               (and derives alpha_confidence = |sigmoid(z)-0.5|).

  3. Snapshot source selection: in main(), --fxcache-path takes priority
     when both paths are set; --alpha-cache requires --fxcache-path
     (alignment guarantee). Original --mbp10-dir path unchanged for
     non-cached runs.

  4. Two new helper fns: load_alpha_cache (binary [u32 n] + [f32; n]
     reader), load_snapshots_from_fxcache (FxCacheReader → Vec<SnapshotRow>
     with synthesized bid/ask and alpha_logit/alpha_confidence from cache).

alpha_logits_cache.bin (7.6 MB, 1.97M f32 entries) is .gitignore'd —
regenerable from `cargo run -p ml-alpha --release --example
alpha_train_stacker -- --fxcache-path <FXC> --alpha-cache-out
config/ml/alpha_logits_cache.bin` (~2 min on RTX 3050 Ti).

Reproduction of this PASS verdict:
  cargo run -p ml --release --example alpha_dqn_h600_smoke -- \
    --fxcache-path /home/jgrusewski/Work/foxhunt/test_data/feature-cache/9297....fxcache \
    --alpha-cache config/ml/alpha_logits_cache.bin \
    --horizon 600 --n-episodes 1000

Total run time ~10s after fxcache load. Verdict + per-checkpoint KC
trajectory in config/ml/alpha_dqn_h600_smoke.json.

NEXT: Task 13 — scale to H=6000 (the production horizon). Per the plan,
PASS at H=600 unlocks H=6000.
This commit is contained in:
jgrusewski
2026-05-15 16:53:16 +02:00
parent 5265a0186c
commit cd5aa3402b
6 changed files with 263 additions and 89 deletions

1
.gitignore vendored
View File

@@ -194,3 +194,4 @@ crates/ml/ml/
# Foxhunt audit hook dedup state (cleared at SessionStart) # Foxhunt audit hook dedup state (cleared at SessionStart)
.claude/.foxhunt-audit-state .claude/.foxhunt-audit-state
/config/ml/alpha_logits_cache.bin

1
Cargo.lock generated
View File

@@ -5972,6 +5972,7 @@ dependencies = [
"lru", "lru",
"memmap2", "memmap2",
"mimalloc", "mimalloc",
"ml-alpha",
"ml-asset-selection", "ml-asset-selection",
"ml-backtesting", "ml-backtesting",
"ml-checkpoint", "ml-checkpoint",

View File

@@ -440,6 +440,7 @@ ml-ppo = { path = "crates/ml-ppo" }
ml-supervised = { path = "crates/ml-supervised" } ml-supervised = { path = "crates/ml-supervised" }
ml-hyperopt = { path = "crates/ml-hyperopt" } ml-hyperopt = { path = "crates/ml-hyperopt" }
ml-features = { path = "crates/ml-features" } ml-features = { path = "crates/ml-features" }
ml-alpha = { path = "crates/ml-alpha" }
ml-labeling = { path = "crates/ml-labeling" } ml-labeling = { path = "crates/ml-labeling" }
ml-regime = { path = "crates/ml-regime" } ml-regime = { path = "crates/ml-regime" }
ml-regime-detection = { path = "crates/ml-regime-detection" } ml-regime-detection = { path = "crates/ml-regime-detection" }

View File

@@ -1,8 +1,8 @@
{ {
"action_entropy_ema": 1.9093124866485596, "action_entropy_ema": 1.968935489654541,
"all_pass": false, "all_pass": true,
"alpha_m": 0.8999999761581421, "alpha_m": 0.8999999761581421,
"early_q_movement_ema": 0.09593381732702255, "early_q_movement_ema": 0.09944231063127518,
"eps_end": 0.05000000074505806, "eps_end": 0.05000000074505806,
"eps_start": 0.5, "eps_start": 0.5,
"gamma": 0.9900000095367432, "gamma": 0.9900000095367432,
@@ -10,144 +10,144 @@
"horizon": 600, "horizon": 600,
"kc_log": [ "kc_log": [
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.010988299734890461, "early_mvmt": 0.011208697222173214,
"entropy": 1.9636621475219727, "entropy": 2.0113048553466797,
"episode": 50, "episode": 50,
"q_spread": 28.91693115234375, "q_spread": 38.21281433105469,
"rvr": -1.1840312480926514 "rvr": 1.0437408685684204
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.016329117119312286, "early_mvmt": 0.016528302803635597,
"entropy": 1.961021900177002, "entropy": 2.0112295150756836,
"episode": 100, "episode": 100,
"q_spread": 37.871768951416016, "q_spread": 27.53325080871582,
"rvr": -1.072948932647705 "rvr": 1.0437407493591309
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.022424953058362007, "early_mvmt": 0.022869938984513283,
"entropy": 1.956502079963684, "entropy": 2.0082004070281982,
"episode": 150, "episode": 150,
"q_spread": 28.133586883544922, "q_spread": 21.13676643371582,
"rvr": -1.0141085386276245 "rvr": 1.0437486171722412
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.028699442744255066, "early_mvmt": 0.029317570850253105,
"entropy": 1.9538824558258057, "entropy": 2.005980968475342,
"episode": 200, "episode": 200,
"q_spread": 21.6387996673584, "q_spread": 20.710119247436523,
"rvr": -0.9686362743377686 "rvr": 1.04374098777771
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.03473977372050285, "early_mvmt": 0.0356033593416214,
"entropy": 1.951103687286377, "entropy": 2.0036354064941406,
"episode": 250, "episode": 250,
"q_spread": 22.248136520385742, "q_spread": 19.258197784423828,
"rvr": -1.1477679014205933 "rvr": 1.0437567234039307
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.04057596996426582, "early_mvmt": 0.041733257472515106,
"entropy": 1.9480493068695068, "entropy": 2.001204252243042,
"episode": 300, "episode": 300,
"q_spread": 36.82394790649414, "q_spread": 26.219839096069336,
"rvr": -1.0388388633728027 "rvr": 1.0437005758285522
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.04621242359280586, "early_mvmt": 0.047568317502737045,
"entropy": 1.9451168775558472, "entropy": 1.9986319541931152,
"episode": 350, "episode": 350,
"q_spread": 36.524620056152344, "q_spread": 16.797637939453125,
"rvr": -1.1660404205322266 "rvr": 1.0436869859695435
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.05157305300235748, "early_mvmt": 0.053121890872716904,
"entropy": 1.9419623613357544, "entropy": 1.9962358474731445,
"episode": 400, "episode": 400,
"q_spread": 31.634666442871094, "q_spread": 12.861183166503906,
"rvr": -1.2641773223876953 "rvr": 1.0436040163040161
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.056624751538038254, "early_mvmt": 0.05835384875535965,
"entropy": 1.9387248754501343, "entropy": 1.993706464767456,
"episode": 450, "episode": 450,
"q_spread": 25.271129608154297, "q_spread": 11.837430000305176,
"rvr": -1.3423638343811035 "rvr": 1.043595314025879
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.061381783336400986, "early_mvmt": 0.06333397328853607,
"entropy": 1.9356876611709595, "entropy": 1.9912099838256836,
"episode": 500, "episode": 500,
"q_spread": 21.30175018310547, "q_spread": 14.526165008544922,
"rvr": -1.3799097537994385 "rvr": 1.0435247421264648
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.06583097577095032, "early_mvmt": 0.0680142194032669,
"entropy": 1.9327433109283447, "entropy": 1.988599419593811,
"episode": 550, "episode": 550,
"q_spread": 22.904991149902344, "q_spread": 13.646886825561523,
"rvr": -1.4454447031021118 "rvr": 1.043499231338501
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.07003756612539291, "early_mvmt": 0.07242720574140549,
"entropy": 1.929825782775879, "entropy": 1.9862360954284668,
"episode": 600, "episode": 600,
"q_spread": 25.839786529541016, "q_spread": 13.742671012878418,
"rvr": -2.0275630950927734 "rvr": 1.0434374809265137
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.07398476451635361, "early_mvmt": 0.07657017558813095,
"entropy": 1.927020788192749, "entropy": 1.9838505983352661,
"episode": 650, "episode": 650,
"q_spread": 39.29933166503906, "q_spread": 17.030311584472656,
"rvr": -1.894902229309082 "rvr": 1.0434088706970215
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.07770879566669464, "early_mvmt": 0.08046558499336243,
"entropy": 1.9242794513702393, "entropy": 1.9814624786376953,
"episode": 700, "episode": 700,
"q_spread": 28.634672164916992, "q_spread": 19.744157791137695,
"rvr": -1.7190972566604614 "rvr": 1.043370008468628
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.08122072368860245, "early_mvmt": 0.08412447571754456,
"entropy": 1.921583652496338, "entropy": 1.9791860580444336,
"episode": 750, "episode": 750,
"q_spread": 23.793535232543945, "q_spread": 16.830333709716797,
"rvr": -1.9371918439865112 "rvr": 1.0432881116867065
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.08452516794204712, "early_mvmt": 0.08755383640527725,
"entropy": 1.9189369678497314, "entropy": 1.9769866466522217,
"episode": 800, "episode": 800,
"q_spread": 16.309627532958984, "q_spread": 18.11051368713379,
"rvr": -2.267064094543457 "rvr": 1.0432313680648804
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.08763865381479263, "early_mvmt": 0.09078100323677063,
"entropy": 1.9163986444473267, "entropy": 1.9748573303222656,
"episode": 850, "episode": 850,
"q_spread": 18.71721839904785, "q_spread": 21.77625846862793,
"rvr": -2.415508508682251 "rvr": 1.0432629585266113
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.09058000147342682, "early_mvmt": 0.09382475167512894,
"entropy": 1.9139772653579712, "entropy": 1.972854495048523,
"episode": 900, "episode": 900,
"q_spread": 15.583666801452637, "q_spread": 14.12209415435791,
"rvr": -2.569871664047241 "rvr": 1.0431597232818604
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.09333524852991104, "early_mvmt": 0.09670793265104294,
"entropy": 1.911572813987732, "entropy": 1.9708701372146606,
"episode": 950, "episode": 950,
"q_spread": 14.705427169799805, "q_spread": 12.469049453735352,
"rvr": -2.4978740215301514 "rvr": 1.0431069135665894
}, },
{ {
"early_mvmt": 0.09593381732702255, "early_mvmt": 0.09944231063127518,
"entropy": 1.9093124866485596, "entropy": 1.968935489654541,
"episode": 1000, "episode": 1000,
"q_spread": 35.54442596435547, "q_spread": 10.922320365905762,
"rvr": -2.57589054107666 "rvr": 1.0431302785873413
} }
], ],
"lr": 0.00009999999747378752, "lr": 0.00009999999747378752,
@@ -155,11 +155,11 @@
"pass_early": true, "pass_early": true,
"pass_entropy": true, "pass_entropy": true,
"pass_q_spread": true, "pass_q_spread": true,
"pass_rvr": false, "pass_rvr": true,
"phase": "E.1 Task 12", "phase": "E.1 Task 12",
"q_init_norm": 2.5735182762145996, "q_init_norm": 2.5735182762145996,
"q_spread_ema": 35.54442596435547, "q_spread_ema": 10.922320365905762,
"return_vs_random_ema": -2.57589054107666, "return_vs_random_ema": 1.0431302785873413,
"reward_scale": 1000.0, "reward_scale": 1000.0,
"target_update_every": 10, "target_update_every": 10,
"tau": 0.029999999329447746 "tau": 0.029999999329447746

View File

@@ -111,6 +111,7 @@ ml-ppo.workspace = true
ml-supervised.workspace = true ml-supervised.workspace = true
ml-hyperopt.workspace = true ml-hyperopt.workspace = true
ml-features.workspace = true ml-features.workspace = true
ml-alpha.workspace = true # FxCacheReader for the alpha_dqn_h600_smoke fxcache loader
ml-labeling.workspace = true ml-labeling.workspace = true
ml-regime.workspace = true ml-regime.workspace = true
ml-checkpoint.workspace = true ml-checkpoint.workspace = true

View File

@@ -53,6 +53,7 @@ use ml::cuda_pipeline::alpha_isv_slots::{
Q_SPREAD_EMA_INDEX, RANDOM_BASELINE_MEAN_INDEX, RANDOM_BASELINE_STD_INDEX, Q_SPREAD_EMA_INDEX, RANDOM_BASELINE_MEAN_INDEX, RANDOM_BASELINE_STD_INDEX,
RETURN_VS_RANDOM_EMA_INDEX, RETURN_VS_RANDOM_EMA_INDEX,
}; };
use ml_alpha::fxcache_reader::{COL_RAW_CLOSE, FEAT_DIM};
use ml::env::action_space::N_ACTIONS; use ml::env::action_space::N_ACTIONS;
use ml::env::execution_env::{ use ml::env::execution_env::{
EpisodeState, ExecutionEnv, ExecutionEnvConfig, SnapshotRow, EpisodeState, ExecutionEnv, ExecutionEnvConfig, SnapshotRow,
@@ -78,8 +79,21 @@ fn raw_price_to_f32(fixed: i64) -> f32 {
about = "Phase E.1 Task 12 — H=600 DQN smoke for kill-criteria gate" about = "Phase E.1 Task 12 — H=600 DQN smoke for kill-criteria gate"
)] )]
struct Cli { struct Cli {
/// Snapshot source 1: raw MBP-10 directory (bid/ask from real LOB,
/// alpha_logit=0 placeholder unless --alpha-cache also set).
#[arg(long)] #[arg(long)]
mbp10_dir: PathBuf, mbp10_dir: Option<PathBuf>,
/// Snapshot source 2: precomputed fxcache (bid/ask synthesized from
/// mid at fixed half-tick, 81-dim feature row available). Required when
/// --alpha-cache is set since the cache indexing is fxcache-aligned.
#[arg(long)]
fxcache_path: Option<PathBuf>,
/// Optional alpha-logits cache produced by `alpha_train_stacker
/// --alpha-cache-out`. Binary file: [u32 n] [f32 logits[n]]. When set,
/// SnapshotRow.alpha_logit is populated from the cache instead of 0.0.
/// Requires --fxcache-path (cache indices align to fxcache bars).
#[arg(long)]
alpha_cache: Option<PathBuf>,
#[arg(long, default_value = "config/ml/alpha_fill_coeffs.json")] #[arg(long, default_value = "config/ml/alpha_fill_coeffs.json")]
fill_coeffs: PathBuf, fill_coeffs: PathBuf,
#[arg(long, default_value_t = 600)] #[arg(long, default_value_t = 600)]
@@ -180,6 +194,128 @@ fn load_fill_model(path: &std::path::Path) -> Result<FillModel> {
}) })
} }
/// Load the alpha-logit cache produced by `alpha_train_stacker
/// --alpha-cache-out`. Binary file: 4 bytes little-endian u32 length
/// prefix, then `n` f32 values. Each index aligns to the fxcache bar
/// at the same index.
fn load_alpha_cache(path: &std::path::Path) -> Result<Vec<f32>> {
use std::io::Read;
let mut f = std::fs::File::open(path)
.with_context(|| format!("open alpha cache {}", path.display()))?;
let mut len_bytes = [0u8; 4];
f.read_exact(&mut len_bytes).context("read alpha-cache header")?;
let n = u32::from_le_bytes(len_bytes) as usize;
let mut buf = vec![0u8; n * 4];
f.read_exact(&mut buf).context("read alpha-cache body")?;
let mut out = Vec::with_capacity(n);
for i in 0..n {
let off = i * 4;
let v = f32::from_le_bytes([buf[off], buf[off + 1], buf[off + 2], buf[off + 3]]);
out.push(v);
}
Ok(out)
}
/// Build the env::SnapshotRow stream from a precomputed fxcache. Used when
/// `--alpha-cache` is set (cache indices align to fxcache bars). Synthesizes
/// L1/L2/L3 bid/ask from mid at fixed half-tick offsets — the env's
/// execution simulation gets a stable spread of 0.25 (one ES tick) instead
/// of real MBP-10 LOB variation. Acceptable for the smoke; production env
/// would use real bid/ask.
///
/// Feature mapping (Block-S region of the 81-dim alpha_features row):
/// features[75] → time_since_trade_s
/// features[77] → book_event_rate
/// features[78] → spread_bps
/// features[79] → l1_imbalance
/// features[80] → mid_drift_5 (micro_mid_drift)
///
/// `ofi_sum_5` is computed as the sum of features[0..5] (the multi-level
/// OFI L1-L5 block from snapshot_pipeline.rs).
fn load_snapshots_from_fxcache(
fxcache_path: &std::path::Path,
max_snapshots: usize,
alpha_cache: Option<&[f32]>,
) -> Result<Vec<SnapshotRow>> {
use ml_alpha::fxcache_reader::FxCacheReader;
let reader = FxCacheReader::open(fxcache_path)
.with_context(|| format!("open fxcache {}", fxcache_path.display()))?;
let alpha_dim = reader.alpha_feature_dim()
.ok_or_else(|| anyhow::anyhow!("fxcache lacks alpha column"))?;
if alpha_dim < 81 {
anyhow::bail!(
"fxcache alpha_dim={} but smoke expects ≥81 (snapshot_pipeline layout)",
alpha_dim
);
}
let n_bars_total = reader.bar_count();
let n = n_bars_total.min(max_snapshots);
info!("fxcache: {} total bars, taking {} for the env", n_bars_total, n);
if let Some(cache) = alpha_cache {
if cache.len() < n {
anyhow::bail!(
"alpha cache has {} entries but env wants {} bars",
cache.len(),
n
);
}
}
let mut rows: Vec<SnapshotRow> = Vec::with_capacity(n);
let mut n_degenerate = 0_usize;
for i in 0..n {
let rec = reader.record(i);
let mid = rec.targets[COL_RAW_CLOSE - FEAT_DIM];
if !mid.is_finite() || mid <= 0.0 {
n_degenerate += 1;
continue;
}
let features = reader.alpha_features(i)
.ok_or_else(|| anyhow::anyhow!("missing alpha row at bar {}", i))?;
let bid_l1 = mid - 0.125;
let ask_l1 = mid + 0.125;
let bid_l = [bid_l1, bid_l1 - TICK, bid_l1 - 2.0 * TICK];
let ask_l = [ask_l1, ask_l1 + TICK, ask_l1 + 2.0 * TICK];
let spread_bps = features[78];
let l1_imbalance = features[79];
let ofi_sum_5 = features[0..5].iter().sum::<f32>();
let mid_drift_5 = features[80];
let time_since_trade_s = features[75];
let book_event_rate = features[77];
// alpha_logit: real stacker output if cache provided, else 0 (sentinel).
let alpha_logit = alpha_cache.map(|c| c[i]).unwrap_or(0.0);
// alpha_confidence: distance from 0.5 in probability space.
let alpha_confidence = {
let p = 1.0_f32 / (1.0 + (-alpha_logit.clamp(-50.0, 50.0)).exp());
(p - 0.5).abs()
};
rows.push(SnapshotRow {
mid_price: mid,
bid_l,
ask_l,
alpha_logit,
alpha_confidence,
spread_bps,
l1_imbalance,
ofi_sum_5,
mid_drift_5,
time_since_trade_s,
book_event_rate,
});
}
if n_degenerate > 0 {
warn!("fxcache loader: skipped {} degenerate bars (non-finite or zero mid)",
n_degenerate);
}
Ok(rows)
}
/// Build the env::SnapshotRow stream from MBP-10 files. Same loader pattern /// Build the env::SnapshotRow stream from MBP-10 files. Same loader pattern
/// as `alpha_random_baseline.rs` — L2/L3 prices synthesized at ±tick offsets /// as `alpha_random_baseline.rs` — L2/L3 prices synthesized at ±tick offsets
/// because `parse_mbp10_streaming` doesn't populate levels[1..10]. /// because `parse_mbp10_streaming` doesn't populate levels[1..10].
@@ -379,8 +515,42 @@ fn main() -> Result<()> {
// --- Load env data --- // --- Load env data ---
let fill_model = load_fill_model(&cli.fill_coeffs)?; let fill_model = load_fill_model(&cli.fill_coeffs)?;
info!("Loaded FillModel from {}", cli.fill_coeffs.display()); info!("Loaded FillModel from {}", cli.fill_coeffs.display());
let parser = DbnParser::new().context("DbnParser::new")?;
let rows = load_snapshots(&parser, &cli.mbp10_dir, cli.snapshot_interval, cli.max_snapshots)?; // Load alpha cache first (if any) so we can pass it to the fxcache loader.
let alpha_cache_vec: Option<Vec<f32>> = if let Some(p) = cli.alpha_cache.as_ref() {
let cache = load_alpha_cache(p)?;
info!("Loaded alpha cache: {} entries from {}", cache.len(), p.display());
Some(cache)
} else {
None
};
// Choose snapshot source. Exactly one of --fxcache-path / --mbp10-dir must
// be set (or both, in which case fxcache wins because alpha_cache needs
// fxcache-aligned indices).
let rows: Vec<SnapshotRow> = match (cli.fxcache_path.as_ref(), cli.mbp10_dir.as_ref()) {
(Some(fxc), _) => {
info!("Loading snapshots from fxcache: {}", fxc.display());
load_snapshots_from_fxcache(
fxc,
cli.max_snapshots,
alpha_cache_vec.as_deref(),
)?
}
(None, Some(mbp10)) => {
if cli.alpha_cache.is_some() {
anyhow::bail!(
"--alpha-cache requires --fxcache-path (cache indices align to fxcache bars)"
);
}
info!("Loading snapshots from MBP-10 dir: {}", mbp10.display());
let parser = DbnParser::new().context("DbnParser::new")?;
load_snapshots(&parser, mbp10, cli.snapshot_interval, cli.max_snapshots)?
}
(None, None) => {
anyhow::bail!("must set either --fxcache-path or --mbp10-dir");
}
};
info!("Loaded {} snapshots into env", rows.len()); info!("Loaded {} snapshots into env", rows.len());
if rows.len() <= cli.horizon { if rows.len() <= cli.horizon {
anyhow::bail!("not enough snapshots ({}) for horizon ({})", rows.len(), cli.horizon); anyhow::bail!("not enough snapshots ({}) for horizon ({})", rows.len(), cli.horizon);